Smaller Font Default Font Larger Font

You are here:

Research Resources: Comparison of Virus-based Gene Delivery Systems

 

 

 

 

Many virus-based gene delivery systems have been developed to exploit viral transduction for inheritable or sustainable expression of a transgene in model organisms. The following table provides a comparison of key features of 4 major virus-based delivery systems, adenovirus, adeno-associated virus (AAV), retrovirus, and lentivirus. Each system has advantages and disadvantages.  For examples,  all 4 systems show broad tropism, capable of transducing a wdie range of host, tissue and cell types.  Adenovirus has high transduction efficicency and is easy to amplify to high titers (>1012 TU/ml).  Adenovirus does not integrate into the host genome, but it induces strong inflammatory response when administered in vivo.  In contrast, AAV is almost non-pathogenic and triggers little or no immune response.  However AAV has the smallest packaging capacity (4-5 kb only) among all 4 systems. Retrovirus can only transduce dividing cells, while other 3 systems can infect both dividing and non-dividing cells.  A unique feature of retroviral and lentiviral systems is that they produce replication defective viral particles. This allows for the delivery of the desired transgene without continued viral replication in the target cells, thus, eliminating the dangers associated with the use of a live pathogen.  However the risk of genome integration-induced mutagenesis and potential activation of oncogenesis limits the clincal applications of retroviral and lentiviral systems.

 

 

 Comparison of Different Viral Gene Delivery Systems

 

 Property Adenovirus AAV Retrovirus Lentivirus
 Viral genome ssDNA ssDNA RNA RNA
 Packaging capacity ~8-30 kb ~5 kb ~7 kb ~8 kb
 Transfection of non-dividing cells yes yes no yes
 Broad transducing tropism yes yes

yes

(dividing cells only)

yes
 Inflammatory (immune) response high low/no low low
 Stable integration into host genome

no

(100% episomal)

yes

(>90% episomal)

yes yes
 Possibility to be pseudotyped  no yes yes yes
 Duration of transgene expression in vivo

Short

(10 days to weeks)

Long

(2.5-6 months)

Days to months

Long

(>12 months)

 Potential genotoxicity Low Low Integration may induce oncogenesis Integration may induce oncogenesis
 

 

 

 

»  Go to the next topic: Introduction to Retrovirus and Lentivirus

 

« Return to Technical Support main page

 

Special Offers & Rewards

Promotion

Earn discounts, credits or rewards with your purchases.

Purchase or Clone My Genes

My Gene Clones

Get the sequence-verified, expression-ready gene clones.

Recombinant Proteins

Recombinant Proteins

Oder your high-quality, recombinant proteins of interest.

Recombinant Antibodies

Recombinant Antibodies

Try our products & services for your antibody R&D.

Virus-Based Gene Expression

Virus Gene Delivery

Acquire high titer, ready-to-use viral particles.

Get in Touch with Us

Send your question or feedback on our products & services